Free tool for agents and small employers

ICHRA vs group plan calculator

See whether moving from a group plan to an ICHRA helps or hurts each employee. Enter the allowance, what the group plan costs today and where each employee lives. The calculator prices their Marketplace plans with live CMS data, runs the IRS affordability test, and checks whether they would do better turning down the ICHRA for the premium tax credit.

1. The employer’s offer, per month

The ICHRA allowance you are considering, and what the group plan costs today at each tier.

Employee only
ICHRA allowance
$
Employee pays for group
$
Employer pays for group
$
Employee + spouse
ICHRA allowance
$
Employee pays for group
$
Employer pays for group
$
Employee + child(ren)
ICHRA allowance
$
Employee pays for group
$
Employer pays for group
$
Family
ICHRA allowance
$
Employee pays for group
$
Employer pays for group
$

A blank allowance uses the employee-only amount. Fill in the group costs for every tier your employees are on; the employer’s share is optional and only feeds the employer cost comparison.

2. Employees

Where each employee lives, who they would cover, and their household income. Up to 25 employees.

Employee 1

Uses Marketplace premiums from CMS (HealthCare.gov states) and the IRS affordability percentage. State-based exchanges such as California and New York are not covered.

Questions employers ask

What is an ICHRA?
An individual coverage health reimbursement arrangement (ICHRA) lets an employer give employees a set monthly amount, tax-free, to buy their own individual health insurance instead of offering a group plan. Employees must be enrolled in individual coverage, such as a Marketplace plan, to use it.
When is an ICHRA affordable?
Take the monthly premium of the lowest-cost Silver plan for the employee alone in the area where they live, and subtract the monthly ICHRA allowance for employee-only coverage. If what is left is no more than 10.22% of household income divided by 12 (for 2027), the ICHRA is affordable for that employee.
Can employees get the premium tax credit with an ICHRA?
Not while they accept it. If the ICHRA is affordable, no one offered it can get the premium tax credit, even by turning it down. If it is unaffordable, the employee can opt out of the ICHRA and the household can use the premium tax credit instead. This calculator picks whichever costs the household less.
Does the family glitch fix apply to ICHRAs?
No. The 2022 IRS rule that tests family members separately applies to group coverage. For an ICHRA, affordability for the whole family is still based on the employee’s self-only test, so an affordable ICHRA blocks the spouse and children from the credit too.
Why can a bigger allowance make some employees worse off?
Lower-income employees often get a premium tax credit larger than the ICHRA. Raising the allowance can make the ICHRA affordable for them, which takes away their right to the credit. The calculator shows the allowance at which each employee crosses that line.
What does this calculator leave out?
It compares premiums on the benchmark Silver plan, not deductibles, networks or drug coverage, and it treats the group plan contribution as what the employee pays today. It uses CMS data for HealthCare.gov states; state-based exchanges such as California and New York are not covered. Employers can set allowances by employee class and age; this compares one allowance per coverage tier.

Checking a group plan instead? Use the family glitch calculator or the ACA subsidy calculator.

Sources: IRS: Premium Tax Credit, 26 CFR 1.36B-2(c)(5), HealthCare.gov: ICHRA, Rev. Proc. 2026-26. Premiums from the CMS Marketplace API.