Medicare

How to quote Medicare Advantage, Part D and Medigap: a step-by-step for agents

By the QuoteDeck team · Updated · 4 min read

The short answer

To quote Medicare well, first collect the client’s zip code and county, Part A and Part B dates, current coverage, prescriptions, doctors, and Medicaid or Extra Help status. Get a completed Scope of Appointment before discussing Medicare Advantage or Part D plans, compare plans on total yearly cost with the client’s drugs and confirm their doctors are in network, then present Medigap and Medicare Advantage options side by side.

Step 1: Collect what changes the answer

Most bad Medicare recommendations come from missing information, not from picking the wrong plan. Before you quote, collect:

  • Zip code and county. Medicare Advantage and Part D plans are sold by county, so a zip code that spans two counties can change the plan list.
  • Age, Part A and Part B effective dates. These decide whether the client is in their Initial Enrollment Period or Medigap Open Enrollment Period.
  • Current coverage and why they want to change. Leaving an employer plan, a Medigap policy or a Medicare Advantage plan each has different timing and risks.
  • Every prescription with strength, dose and quantity, and the pharmacy they use.
  • Doctors and the specific office they visit, plus any hospital they want to keep.
  • Medicaid level or Extra Help status, which opens Special Needs Plans and lowers drug costs.
  • Health conditions, which matter for Chronic Condition SNPs and for Medigap underwriting outside the open enrollment period.
  • A monthly budget, so you can show options the client will actually keep.

Step 2: Get the Scope of Appointment before discussing plans

CMS requires a completed Scope of Appointment before a personal marketing appointment that covers Medicare Advantage or Part D plans. For 2027 the 48-hour waiting period is gone, so the appointment can happen right after the SOA is signed. Medigap is regulated by the states rather than CMS marketing rules, but if the conversation may turn to Medicare Advantage or Part D, collect the SOA first. Give the TPMO disclaimer verbally before you discuss benefits.

Scope of Appointment rules for 2027

TPMO disclaimer rules for 2027

Step 3: Compare Medicare Advantage and Part D on total cost

  1. Enter every drug and look at the estimated yearly drug cost for each plan, not just the premium. A $0 premium plan can cost more than a plan with a premium once drugs are counted.
  2. Check each drug’s tier and any prior authorization, step therapy or quantity limits.
  3. Use the client’s pharmacy. Preferred pharmacies can change copays a lot.
  4. Confirm each doctor is in network at the office the client actually visits, and check the carrier’s provider directory when you cannot confirm it.
  5. Compare the maximum out-of-pocket, inpatient hospital copays per day, specialist copays and the extra benefits the client cares about, such as dental or over-the-counter allowances.

Step 4: Quote Medigap

Medigap plans are standardized: a Plan G pays the same benefits whichever company sells it, so you are comparing price, rate history and how the company sets its premiums. Policies are priced in one of three ways:

How Medigap premiums are set
Rating methodHow the premium is setWhat it means for the client
Community-ratedEveryone pays the same premium regardless of ageCan cost more at 65 but does not rise because of age
Issue-age-ratedBased on age when the policy is boughtBuying younger locks in a lower age rating
Attained-age-ratedBased on current age, rising as the client agesOften cheapest at 65 but rises over time

Under federal law the client has a 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period that starts the first month they have Part B and are 65 or older. During it, a company cannot refuse to sell them a policy or charge more because of their health. Outside that window, companies can usually ask health questions unless the client has a guaranteed issue right, and some states give additional rights.

Medigap Plan G vs Plan N

Step 5: Check Medicaid, Extra Help and Special Needs Plans

  • Clients with Medicaid may qualify for a Dual Eligible Special Needs Plan (D-SNP). Some D-SNPs are open only to certain Medicaid levels, so confirm the level before quoting.
  • Extra Help lowers Part D premiums and drug copays. Clients with limited income and savings should apply even if they are not sure they qualify.
  • Clients with certain chronic conditions, such as diabetes or chronic heart failure, may qualify for a Chronic Condition SNP.
  • A Medicare Savings Program can pay the Part B premium for clients under the state’s income and asset limits.

Free Medicare Savings Program calculator

Step 6: Present Medigap and Medicare Advantage side by side

Present two or three complete packages rather than a list of plans: for example Medigap Plan G with a Part D plan, and a Medicare Advantage plan with hospital indemnity sized to its inpatient copays. Give each a monthly total, explain the trade-offs neutrally, and let the client choose.

QuoteDeck quotes Medicare Advantage, Part D and Medigap with the client’s drugs and doctors, adds dental, hospital indemnity and final expense to the same packages, and sends one presentation link the client can open on their phone.

How to present insurance quotes clients understand

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a Scope of Appointment to quote Medigap?

CMS requires an SOA before discussing Medicare Advantage or Part D plans, not Medigap. If the appointment may cover Medicare Advantage or Part D, collect the SOA first.

When can a client buy Medigap without health questions?

During the 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period that starts the first month they have Part B and are 65 or older, or when they have a guaranteed issue right. Some states give additional rights.

What is the most important number when comparing Medicare Advantage plans?

The estimated yearly cost with the client’s drugs, together with the maximum out-of-pocket. The premium alone is often misleading.

Sources

Checked on November 15, 2026. Rules change, so confirm with the source and your carriers.

This guide is general information for licensed insurance professionals, not legal or compliance advice. Follow CMS, state and carrier requirements that apply to you.

Quote Medicare with the client’s drugs and doctors

Medicare Advantage, Part D and Medigap side by side, with dental and hospital indemnity in the same presentation.

All agent guides · Compare agent software · Medicare quoting software · Insurance quoting software